| 1 | Katie Follett SR Washington | 4:41.84Q |
| 2 | Keri Bland JR West Virginia | 4:41.87Q |
| 3 | Jordan Hasay FR Oregon | 4:41.89Q |
| 4 | Mihaela Susa JR Oklahoma State | 4:42.03Q |
| 5 | Charlotte Browning SR Florida | 4:43.35Q |
| 6 | Anne Kesselring FR Oregon | 4:43.38Q |
| 7 | Dina Nosenko SO Wake Forest | 4:43.61q |
| 8 | Pilar McShine SR Florida State | 4:44.23Q |
| 9 | Caroline Karunde JR Texas Tech | 4:44.45Q |
| 10 | Heidi Gregson SO Iona | 4:46.05q |
| 11 | Kristie Krueger SO Georgia | 4:46.25 |
| 12 | Kaylyn Christopher SO West Virginia | 4:46.76 |
| 13 | Nicole Schappert SR Villanova | 4:47.46 |
| 14 | Purity Biwott JR Texas Tech | 4:50.12 |
| 15 | Amanda Winslow FR Florida State | 4:52.99 |
| 16 | Sharla Manuele SR Southern Utah | 4:54.15 |
| 17 | Ashley Miller JR Nebraska | 4:54.47 |